MARCH 18 – If you work in sustainability, you’ve felt the buzz.It’s the defining challenge of our age, and a new breed of science has risen to meet it: Sustainability...
and enjoy FREE RM10 & when you sign up using code VERSAMM10 with min. cash of RM100 today! T&Cs apply.MARCH 18 – If you work in sustainability, you’ve felt the buzz. It’s the defining challenge of our age, and a new breed of science has risen to meet it: Sustainability Science .
But a decade into its adolescence, a piercing question emerges: Is it delivering on its revolutionary promise? An earlier review by Joachim Spangenberg, still shockingly relevant today, offered a clear-eyed diagnosis: not yet. His analysis suggests the field, for all its noble aims, risks becoming a well-meaning academic bubble – rich in theory but poor in real-world impact.Spangenberg’s core critique is that Sustainability Science is often paralyzed by its own complexity. Its foundational strength – understanding the interconnected “triple bottom line” of environment, society, and economy – becomes a weakness in practice. The systems are so vast, the feedback loops so intricate, that researchers can spend careers mapping problems without ever pointing decisively to solutions.Experts say sustainability research must move beyond theory and engage more directly with real-world transitions in energy, agriculture and development. — Unsplash pic Fragmentation over integration: The field splinters into environmental, social, and economic silos, mirroring the very disciplinary divides it sought to transcend. We get deep dives on carbon cycles or social equity, but fewer genuine syntheses showing how changing one would affect the others. Descriptive, not transformative: Much work excels at describing our unsustainable trajectory but hesitates at the politically and ethically fraught task of prescribing concrete, normative pathways out of it. It’s easier to model a 2°C warmer world than to design the politically viable tax policy to avoid it. Next is political timidity: True sustainability challenges power structures, economic models, and consumption patterns. Yet, Spangenberg argues, the science often pulls its punches, seeking consensus and “win-wins” in spaces where fundamental trade-offs and conflicts of interest are the reality.The prescription: From analysis to agency.He outlines the tough medicine the field must swallow. Embrace transdisciplinarity, not just interdisciplinarity: It’s not enough for ecologists to talk to economists. True transdisciplinarity involves co-creating knowledge with stakeholders – farmers, city planners, community activists – from the outset. The research question itself must be shaped by the needs of those facing the sustainability challenge.This means prototyping, experimenting with alternative systems , and studying transitions.Confront normativity and power head-on: Sustainability is a value-based goal.This means analyzing who wins and loses from current systems and proposed solutions, and engaging with political and economic realities, not shying away from them.The sobering truth in 2026 is that Spangenberg’s critique remains urgent. While pockets of brilliant, transformative work exist, the mainstream of sustainability research, funding, and publishing still often rewards complexity analysis over actionable intervention. The empirical lesson for scientists, policymakers, and funders is this: We must stop rewarding sustainability science merely for being about sustainability.It means promoting researchers who collaborate with communities and policymakers. It means accepting that rigorous science can look like a pilot project for a just energy transition as much as a high-impact factor paper on atmospheric chemistry.It’s time it fully lives up to that ambition, steps out of its comfortable bubble, and embraces its essential, tumultuous role as a catalyst for real-world change.The science meant to guide us out of it cannot afford to be a passive observer. At UCSI University, the recently formed International Institute for Science Diplomacy and Sustainability, IISDS, is well suited to spearhead the change. * The author is affiliated with the Tan Sri Omar Centre for STI Policy Studies at UCSI University and is an adjunct professor at the Ungku Aziz Centre for Development Studies, Universiti Malaya. He can be reached at** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Joachim Spangenberg Transdisciplinarity Circular Economies Agroecology UCSI University
Malaysia Latest News, Malaysia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
PM Anwar Ibrahim Highlights Unity and Consumer Welfare During Sabah VisitPrime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim visited Sabah for the 2026 National Consumers Day celebration, emphasizing the importance of unity and the government's commitment to consumer welfare and the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63). The visit included various events and community engagements.
Read more »
Binatang pun tidak seperti ini – Sarimah IbrahimBinatang pun tidak seperti ini - Sarimah Ibrahim
Read more »
Anwar Ibrahim Donates 14,000 Chickens to Permatang Pauh ResidentsPrime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, through NACCOL, donated 14,000 chickens to residents of the Permatang Pauh parliamentary constituency. The chickens were distributed to 29 mosques before being given to the community, with each mosque receiving between 500 and 700 chickens. Recipient Siti Zaiton Mustafa expressed gratitude for the aid.
Read more »
U Mobile Announces Leadership Transition with Tunku Tun Aminah Sultan Ibrahim as New ChairmanU Mobile Sdn Bhd has appointed Tunku Tun Aminah Sultan Ibrahim as its new chairman, effective March 13, 2026. This follows Tan Sri Vincent Tan Chee Yioun's relinquishment of his position, with Tan transitioning to founder and advisor. Mawar Setia Sdn Bhd, the investment company co-founded by Tan Sri Vincent Tan and Tunku Tun Aminah, increased its equity stake to over 50%.
Read more »
Jalan Tanjong Tokong Lama Renamed to Jalan Shaik IbrahimA portion of Jalan Tanjong Tokong Lama in Penang has been renamed Jalan Shaik Ibrahim to honor the contributions of the late Shaik Ibrahim, a former community leader. The renaming was approved by the state government following requests from local residents and recognizes his significant impact on the Tanjong Tokong community.
Read more »
Hamzah Zainuddin Denies Secret Meetings with Anwar Ibrahim Challenges Azmin AliLarut MP Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainuddin denies allegations of secret meetings with Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim after his expulsion from Bersatu and challenges Bersatu secretary-general Datuk Seri Azmin Ali to clarify alleged meetings with Anwar. He claims that he has not met Anwar outside of Parliament since Anwar became Prime Minister in November 2022. Hamzah was responding to questions about why some Bersatu leaders who openly support Anwar faced no action while he was expelled for meeting Umno president.
Read more »