MARCH 30 — Imagine a village with no clean water or reliable electricity. Now imagine officials arriving not with pipes or wires, but with the latest smartphone app for...
and enjoy FREE RM10 & when you sign up using code VERSAMM10 with min. cash of RM100 today! T&Cs apply.MARCH 30 — Imagine a village with no clean water or reliable electricity. Now imagine officials arriving not with pipes or wires, but with the latest smartphone app for monitoring water quality.
The disconnect is obvious. Yet, this is precisely the dynamic playing out in global health financing, as revealed by a new study of seven low- and middle-income countries. The research, analysing attempts to implement Programme-Based Budgeting , uncovers a persistent and costly illusion: that technocratic budgeting tools can, by themselves, cure the ills of underfunded and inefficient health systems. The findings show a familiar pattern of “adoption without adaptation”, where countries import glossy reform blueprints, only to see them gather dust or become empty rituals.The study points to a fundamental clash between the logic of systems and the logic of power. PBB promises rationality. It shifts focus from merely listing line-items to funding integrated programmes based on their goals and performance. Theoretically, it makes spending more transparent, efficient, and aligned with health priorities. Donors love it. International financial institutions promote it. Governments, eager to signal modernity and competence, sign up. But the political economy — the gritty reality of who holds power, resources, and influence — eats these technical reforms for breakfast. First, PBB threatens established hierarchies. Moving control from central finance ministries to health programme managers disrupts patronage networks. A powerful official who once distributed vehicles or jobs as political favours loses sway if funds are tied to health outcomes instead. Unsurprisingly, these actors often resist, ensuring old parallel systems run alongside the new paperwork. Second, it assumes a level of stability and capacity that simply doesn’t exist. In many contexts, health budgets are chronically late, unpredictable, and subject to arbitrary cuts. Frontline managers live in a world of crisis and improvisation. Asking them to meticulously plan and report on multi-year programmes is like asking a sailor in a storm to chart a perfect course with a broken compass. The reform becomes a burdensome reporting exercise for donors, disconnected from the chaotic reality of moving money to clinics. Third, the “implementers” are often set up to fail. The study found that mid-level technical staff, tasked with making PBB work, are frequently caught in the crossfire. They lack the political clout to enforce new rules against powerful opponents and are given responsibility without real authority. The result is disillusionment, “checkbox” compliance, and a reform that exists in name only. The core lesson is stark: A budget is not just a technical document; it is a fossil record of political choices. It reveals who and what a state truly values. You cannot change the budget’s structure without changing the underlying power dynamics that shape it. This doesn’t mean we should abandon tools like PBB. It means we must stop treating them as magic bullets. Our health systems don’t need more sophisticated apps. They need reliable electricity and clean water. — Unsplash pic The research suggests a more humble, politically-smart path forward: Start with coalition-building, not software. Before launching a complex reform, invest in creating a constituency for change within and outside government. Engage parliamentarians, civil society, and professional associations who can demand greater transparency and hold power to account.There’s little point in advanced performance metrics if the fundamental plumbing — timely release of funds, basic financial management — is broken. Sequence reforms to build a stable foundation. Embrace “good enough” and adaptation. Instead of importing a full, perfect model, identify one or two priority health areas where a program-based approach could genuinely solve a local problem.Follow the incentives. Align the reform with the political and professional incentives of key actors. Can PBB help a minister demonstrate tangible success to the public? Can it help a local manager get resources faster? If the answer is no, resistance is inevitable. The goal of better health financing is too important to be derailed by another cycle of reform theatre. It’s time to move beyond the allure of technocratic fixes and grapple with the harder, more human work of building accountability, strengthening institutions, and negotiating political consensus. Our health systems don’t need more sophisticated apps. They need reliable electricity and clean water — the foundational governance and political commitment to make any tool work.Political economy of budgeting reforms: a comparative analysis of the adoption and implementation of programme-based budgeting in health across seven LMIC countriesThis exposes the reality of the political economy in national budgeting. Reform is challenging but not impossible. * The author is affiliated with the Tan Sri Omar Centre for STI Policy Studies at UCSI University and is an Adjunct Professor at the Ungku Aziz Centre for Development Studies, Universiti Malaya. He can be reached at** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of
Global Health Financing Political Economy Budgeting Reforms Low- And Middle-Income Countries Tan Sri Omar Centre
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Anwar Ibrahim Congratulates Syed Saddiq on Engagement to Bella AstillahPrime Minister Anwar Ibrahim congratulated Muar MP Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman on his engagement to actress and singer Bella Astillah. Anwar humorously requested an invitation to their future wedding, which confirmed recent speculations about their relationship. Syed Saddiq announced the engagement on Facebook, revealing he proposed to Bella on Mount Kinabalu.
Read more »
“Use EVs, bicycles & carpool to work” – Ahmad Maslan Proposes 7 Measures to Tackle Rising Fuel CostsDeputy Minister of Works Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad bin Maslan has put forth seven suggestions to address the issue of rising petrol and diesel prices amid the
Read more »
Ahmad Aslam's Divorce and Reconciliation Case: Court to Decide on Marital StatusSocial media influencer Ahmad Aslam is facing legal proceedings to confirm divorce and reconciliation pronouncements with his wife, Marissa Dania Hakim. The court will determine the couple's marital status following out-of-court pronouncements. Details of the case include a previous marriage in Thailand and complex family dynamics.
Read more »
Ahmad Maslan’s 7-Point Fuel Fix: Sounds Good, But Short On RealityThe ideas sound like textbook answers: Cycle, take public transport, have money to buy EV, among others.
Read more »
Social Media Influencer Ahmad Aslam Silent on Divorce Proceedings, Asks for PrayersSocial media influencer Ahmad Aslam declined to comment on the ongoing court proceedings regarding the confirmation of his divorce and reconciliation with his second wife, Marissa Dania Hakim. The court has yet to make a final decision, citing the need for further legal and religious examination. The couple has requested privacy regarding the next hearing date and is reportedly still living together.
Read more »
Sharnaaz Ahmad's Son Jebat Jayden Receives Impressive Raya CollectionEight-year-old Jebat Jayden, son of actor Sharnaaz Ahmad, revealed a substantial Hari Raya collection including RM18,369 and gold bars. Netizens expressed amazement at his good fortune, with gifts from close relatives including Neelofa.
Read more »