The Court of Appeal says the High Court did not err in concluding that the transfer instruments were forgeries.
The Court of Appeal ordered the appellants to pay the respondent a total of RM88,000 in costs. PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal has affirmed a High Court ruling ordering the return of five plots of land valued at about RM2.5 million in Tanjung Piandang , Perak, to a former engineer following a fraud that occurred about 10 years ago.
Justice Ong Chee Kwan, delivering the unanimous decision, said the High Court committed no error in concluding that the instruments the appellants relied on for the transfer, including the power of attorney and settlement agreement, were forgeries.
“While the law presumes that a duly authenticated power of attorney is valid, the respondent successfully rebutted that presumption through both direct and circumstantial evidence,” he said in the judgment. He said the appellants also failed to produce the original documents and material witnesses to support their case. Justices Azman Abdullah, the bench chairman, and Ahmad Kamal Shahid also heard the appeal.
The respondent, former engineer Lim Peng Khoon, who was the plaintiff in the High Court, filed his claim in 2018 seeking orders and declarations for the return of lands fraudulently transferred from him. Lim named Tea Chun Hia and her sons, Lee Chee Khoon, Lee Hui Khoon and Lee Wooi Khong, as the defendants.
He also sued the director of the Perak land and mines office, the state registrar of land titles, and the Kerian land administrator for negligence and breach of statutory duty. However, they did not appeal. Lim alleged that Tea and her sons defrauded him of the land, while the state land authorities acted negligently and in breach of their statutory duties, thereby facilitating the fraudulent transfer of the properties.
Tea and her sons appealed to the Court of Appeal, challenging both the procedural propriety of the proceedings leading to the delivery of the judgment and several aspects of the High Court’s findings on the law and evidence. The appellants also challenged the validity of the High Court judgment on grounds that Hui Khoon had been declared bankrupt before the decision was delivered in 2023.
They further disputed the proper approach to the burden of proof concerning the authenticity of the power of attorney. Ong said the appeal primarily concerned proprietary rights, specifically whether the land transfers and supporting documents were valid, rather than the recovery of a debt.
“As such, the High Court was entitled to deliver its judgment without prior leave of the bankruptcy court, although enforcement of any monetary award would still require such leave,” he said. Ong ordered the appellants to pay Lim a total of RM88,000 in costs. The assessment of damages has been remitted to the High Court in Ipoh.
Lawyers Nicholas Kow, Emile Ezra Hussain and Nur Amelia Izlyn Azhari appeared for the appellants, while the respondent was represented by Karin Lim, A Suppiah and Nicholas Lim.
Court Of Appeal Former Engineer Kerian District Land Fraud Mother Power Of Attorney Ruling Sons Tanjung Piandang
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Georgia Supreme Court disciplines prosecutor for AI misuse in murder caseThe Georgia Supreme Court barred a prosecutor from appearing before the justices for six months after she used AI tools that generated fake and misleading case citations in a murder case ruling. The court found numerous fictitious citations in a lower court's order denying a defendant's bid for a new trial, calling the conduct a violation of court rules.
Read more »
High Court Rejects Ratu Naga’s Bid to Refer Constitutional Questions to Federal CourtPolitical activist Syarul Ema Rena Abu Samah, known as Ratu Naga, fails in her High Court attempt to refer constitutional questions to the Federal Court over her detention by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission. The case centers on her claim of being denied legal counsel and the validity of Criminal Procedure Code provisions under Article 5(3) of the Federal Constitution.
Read more »
High Court rejects influencer Ratu Naga’s application to refer legal questions to Federal CourtKUALA LUMPUR, May 6 — The High Court today dismissed Syarul Ema Rena Abu Samah’s bid to refer two questions of law to the Federal Court over being denied legal representation...
Read more »
Kuala Lumpur High Court Dismisses Activist's Bid to Refer Legal Questions to Federal CourtThe Kuala Lumpur High Court rejected Syarul Ema Rena Abu Samah's application to refer two legal questions to the Federal Court regarding her denial of legal representation during MACC questioning. The court ruled that the issue requires a trial to resolve factual disputes and set May 11 for case management. The plaintiff had challenged the constitutionality of certain sections of the Criminal Procedure Code and sought declarations on her rights under the Federal Constitution.
Read more »
Three remanded over RM2.6 mln Labuan MAIWP contract probeLABUAN: A senior assistant engineer at the Labuan Federal Territories Islamic Religious Council (MAIWP), and two company owners, have been remanded fo
Read more »
PGA tahan 41 individu, rampas RM2.7 juta pada AprilLAHAD DATU: Pasukan Gerakan Am (PGA) menahan 41 individu serta merampas pelbagai barangan bernilai lebih RM2.7 juta menerusi operasi berasingan yang dijalankan
Read more »