The Court of Appeal more than doubled the original damages awarded to Louis Vuitton after finding the seller continued advertising and selling counterfeit LV products on Instagram despite an injunction.
The Court of Appeal more than doubled the original damages awarded to Louis Vuitton after finding the seller continued advertising and selling counterfeit LV products on Instagram despite an injunction.
An Instagram seller who marketed counterfeit Louis Vuitton products as"authentic vintage" and"upcycled" luxury items has been ordered to pay the fashion house SGD510,000 after Singapore's highest court ruled the earlier damages award too low In a judgment issued on 6 May, the Court of Appeal more than doubled the original SGD200,000 award granted to Louis Vuitton Malletier , describing the Instagram seller's conduct as"highly flagrant" and accusing him of showing"blatant disregard for the law". The case involved Ng Hoe Seng, who operated Instagram stores under the handles @emcase_sg and later @emcrafts_sg, where he sold products such as phone cases, passport covers, watch straps, card holders, and pouches bearing Louis Vuitton branding.
According to the judgment, Ng claimed the items were made using"authentic vintage 2nd hand materials" and marketed them as"upcycled" luxury goods with"authenticity guaranteed" However, Louis Vuitton conducted trap purchases in 2022 and 2023, with laboratory testing later finding that at least some of the materials used were not genuine Louis Vuitton products. The court heard that Ng continued advertising and selling the products even after Louis Vuitton obtained an injunction against him.
He allegedly shifted operations to another Instagram account and made it private after legal action began. The judges said his conduct showed he was a"recalcitrant violator who showed no respect for court orders". At least 121 instances of trademark infringement were identified across nine categories of products, including phone cases, key cases, pouches, watch straps, card wallets, passport covers, phone bags, spectacle cases, and cigarette cases.
The Court of Appeal ultimately rejected Louis Vuitton's argument that damages should be calculated separately for every infringed trademark, which could have pushed the potential payout into the millions. Instead, the court ruled that statutory damages should be assessed based on each category of counterfeit goods sold, regardless of how many trademarks appeared on each product.
Still, the judges agreed that the original SDG200,000 award was"wholly inadequate", especially given Ng's continued sales activity, evasive behaviour, and use of Instagram to expand his reach. The court noted that social media allowed the seller to"reach a larger audience at a lower cost", while also pointing to the use of influencers under a group called"EmCollabFam" to promote the counterfeit products onlineSGD70,000 each for phone cases, key cases, and pouches/pursesThis brought the total damages awarded to Louis Vuitton to SGD510,000, with Ng also ordered to pay an additional SGD40,000 in legal costs.
Read the full storyMan Who Filmed KL Rain Rave Scuffle Claims Woman Who Pulled Out Knife Was Robbed
Crime Fakeproducts Lifestyle Louisvuitton Luxury News Onlinesellers Phonecase Singaporean
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
High Court rejects influencer Ratu Naga’s application to refer legal questions to Federal CourtKUALA LUMPUR, May 6 — The High Court today dismissed Syarul Ema Rena Abu Samah’s bid to refer two questions of law to the Federal Court over being denied legal representation...
Read more »
Kuala Lumpur High Court Dismisses Activist's Bid to Refer Legal Questions to Federal CourtThe Kuala Lumpur High Court rejected Syarul Ema Rena Abu Samah's application to refer two legal questions to the Federal Court regarding her denial of legal representation during MACC questioning. The court ruled that the issue requires a trial to resolve factual disputes and set May 11 for case management. The plaintiff had challenged the constitutionality of certain sections of the Criminal Procedure Code and sought declarations on her rights under the Federal Constitution.
Read more »
UK court blocks BHP appeal over 2015 Brazil dam collapse liabilityLONDON, May 6 — BHP cannot appeal against a UK ruling that it is liable for the 2015 collapse of a dam in south-eastern Brazil, London’s Court of Appeal ruled today.In...
Read more »
Singapore Court More Than Doubles Damages for Louis Vuitton in Counterfeit Goods CaseThe Court of Appeal in Singapore has more than doubled the damages awarded to Louis Vuitton after an Instagram seller continued to sell counterfeit LV products despite a court injunction. The seller, Ng Hoe Seng, was found to have shown blatant disregard for the law, leading to a total damages award of SGD510,000.
Read more »