Beyond the Breaking News

Contradictheory: Red button, blue button, who gets to watch the World Cup?

Contradictheory News

Contradictheory: Red button, blue button, who gets to watch the World Cup?
Dzof AzmiWorld CupBroadcasting

MIAMI, May 2 (Reuters) - ⁠Ferrari's Charles Leclerc said he had been harsh on Formula One ⁠leader Kimi Antonelli after angrily criticising the Italian teenager in the heat ‌of the Miami Grand Prix sprint race on Saturday.

An archive photo from a 1982 qualifying World Cup match showing France's captain, Michel 'The King' Platini , and Netherlands' Johan Neeskens fighting for the ball.

Back then some of the matches were proudly sponsored by the rakyat – can that happen this year? — AFP Football's World Cup kicks off in about 40 days. The world will be watching, but whether this includes anyone in Malaysia is still an open question at the time of writing. The latest update I have is that Telekom Malaysia is in talks with RTM to secure broadcasting rights.

But even after some reduction from football’s governing body Fifa, the price tag of about US$35mil is too much, especially given the current uncertainty of the global economy. Malaysia has been airing World Cup matches since 1974, although not always showing all the matches. A standout year is 1982, when originally only four matches were scheduled for live broadcast.

Then somebody suggested the public should raise their own funds, and Malaysians collectively raised around RM300,000 to cover the cost of airing four additional games. The phrase “Ditaja oleh rakyat Malaysia” became a source of pride. I was one of those who peered through sleepy eyes at our black and white TV set at home to support Italy and their awesomely-named goalkeeper, Dino Zoff. The obvious question now is, can we do it again?

To answer it, I turn to a different problem entirely: the so-called red button/blue button meme. The premise is simple. Everyone must choose between a red or blue button. If more than half press the blue button, everyone survives.

If not, only those who press the red button survive. To me, the solution is straightforward. If you press blue, your survival depends on others making the same choice. If you press red, you survive regardless of what others do.

From a purely selfish standpoint, red is the safer option. In fact, if everyone chooses red, everyone survives, and no one has an incentive to switch. It becomes something called a Nash equilibrium, and represents a possible “best response” strategy if you don’t know what others will do. It’s something I would encourage everyone to follow.

We need to stand together so that all will survive. It’s like encouraging people to take the vaccine, or to go out and vote, because it’s specifically in your best interest. But my wife and daughter disagree. They would both press blue.

They are willing to take the risk, because they believe that cooperation is better than self-interest. This is also why I love my wife and daughter, while wondering why they love me. And that brings us back to football. Imagine trying to crowdfund the World Cup today.

You would need a critical mass of people willing to contribute before anything happens. In 1982, RM300,000 bought four matches. Adjusted loosely for inflation, that might be just under RM1mil today. But Fifa’s current rights costs work out to roughly RM1.3mil a match, which is a testament to its unwritten policy for this World Cup which goes something like “Why charge less money when you can make more?

” So even if Malaysians could rally behind broadcasting the final, replicating the collective effort of 1982 across multiple matches feels unlikely. It might mean spending a few hundred ringgit too much above what is already a high cost of living. On top of that, we now have a third option: Piracy. With a few clicks, a match appears on your screen.

The stream may lag, the commentary might be in a foreign language, and there may be suspiciously persistent pop-up ads. But it is free, and for many, good enough. There is an analogy with the button game. Contributing to a legal broadcast is like pressing the blue button where you only benefit if enough others do the same.

Meanwhile, piracy is the red button where you get what you want regardless of what everyone else decides. And just like in the thought experiment, the safer individual choice undermines the collective utopian outcome. The more people who choose the red button, the harder it becomes to sustain any shared solution. Over time, the blue buttons die off until everybody is red, or not a football fan.

The companies and market will, of course, adapt to this. During the 2024-2025 season the English Premier League’s anti-piracy team removed more than 230,000 illegal live streams from social media platforms. That same year they also obtained an order from Singapore’s High Court to force Internet service providers to block access to 25 websites that illegally stream EPL football matches.

Then later last year, it was reported that the EPL is preparing to launch its own direct-to-consumer streaming service in Singapore, with potential expansion elsewhere. Why pirate when you can pay to watch it on your own desktop in the comfort of your home for less than the price of a real-life EPL ticket? If that works, it changes the nature of what it means to watch football.

Football, at least at the World Cup level, used to be something shared by everyone, both football fan and non. It was watched in living rooms and at mamak stalls, discussed in office cubicles and at family dinners, together and simultaneously. When access becomes a personal decision, this shared experience is broken. In 1982, Malaysians didn’t just want to watch football, they wanted everyone to be able to watch it too, even those who didn’t or couldn’t contribute.

That is what brought the rakyat together. But if we press the safer button, it will mean that the world’s game will slowly become something we watch on our own. In his fortnightly column Contradictheory, mathematician-turned-scriptwriter Dzof Azmi explores the theory that logic is the antithesis of emotion but people need both to make sense of life’s vagaries and contradictions. Write to Dzof at lifestyle@thestar.com.my.

The views expressed here are entirely the writer's own. Pet owners in the US are cutting vet visits, but still splurge on their furkidsMacarons used to bore me, says French 'Master of Macarons' Pierre Herme

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

staronline /  🏆 4. in MY

Dzof Azmi World Cup Broadcasting Crowdfunding Football Collective Effort

 

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Malaysia's Thomas Cup Journey Ends with Quarter-Final Defeat to ChinaMalaysia's Thomas Cup Journey Ends with Quarter-Final Defeat to ChinaMalaysia's Thomas Cup campaign concluded in the quarter-finals with a 0-3 loss to defending champions China. Leong Jun Hao, Aaron Chia-Soh Wooi Yik, and Justin Hoh all lost their matches, ending Malaysia's run in the tournament.
Read more »

Malaysia Falls to China in Thomas Cup QuarterfinalsMalaysia Falls to China in Thomas Cup QuarterfinalsMalaysia's hopes in the Thomas Cup were dashed as they lost to China in the quarterfinals. Key players Aaron Chia-Soh Wooi Yik, Leong Jun Hao, and Justin Hoh all suffered defeats, leading to a 3-0 loss for the Malaysian team.
Read more »

Malaysia Falls to China in Thomas Cup Quarter-FinalMalaysia Falls to China in Thomas Cup Quarter-FinalMalaysia lost 3-0 to defending champions China in the Thomas Cup Finals quarter-final, despite a strong effort from Aaron Chia-Soh Wooi Yik. The pair suffered their 10th defeat against Liang Weikeng-Wang Chang. The team reflects on the match and looks ahead to future competitions.
Read more »

Malaysia crash out of Thomas Cup quarters, Great Wall of China proves unbreachableMalaysia crash out of Thomas Cup quarters, Great Wall of China proves unbreachableHORSENS (Denmark), May 1 — The Great Wall of China proved too strong to breach.Malaysia’s bid to end 34-year drought of lifting the Thomas Cup during the 2026 edition came to a...
Read more »

Malaysia's Thomas Cup Campaign Ends in Quarter-FinalsMalaysia's Thomas Cup Campaign Ends in Quarter-FinalsMalaysia lost 0-3 to China in the Thomas Cup quarter-finals, ending their title hopes. Justin Hoh, Leong Jun Hao, and the doubles pair Aaron Chia-Soh Wooi Yik all suffered defeats. Justin Hoh acknowledges the need for more experience at the highest level.
Read more »

Jonassen takes responsibility for Malaysia’s Thomas Cup failure, says performance ‘simply not good enough’Jonassen takes responsibility for Malaysia’s Thomas Cup failure, says performance ‘simply not good enough’HORSENS (Denmark), May 2 — Malaysia’s disappointing exit from the Thomas Cup Finals 2026 has prompted a blunt admission from national singles coaching director Kenneth...
Read more »



Render Time: 2026-05-22 23:59:23