SDs and letters of support unreliable, stick to confidence vote in Parliament, say lawyers
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 14 — A confidence vote in Parliament is the best way to test if the prime minister has the support he needs to lead the government, lawyers said. Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin promised last week that he would table a confidence vote in the Dewan Rakyat next month — it’s been scheduled for September 7 — butasked lawyers to weigh in on the clearest and most reliable conclusion to determine the majority, as a slew of statutory declarations and other proclamations from MPs have been circulating wildly on social media, resulting in public confusion.
“A vote in Parliament is the most open and transparent way because the sittings are broadcast live and also would be on official records via the Hansard. “As such, there is little likelihood that the result will be challenged. Compare this with a meeting with the Ruler, or through SDs, which happen behind closed doors and may be questioned,” Syahredzan Johan toldFahri Azzat concurred, saying that methods such as a show of hands or a count to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong or a Sultan, should also be avoided.Fahri added that SDs and letters of support are also unreliable methods, stressing that the documents only point towards a fact of the past. “For example, I affirm an affidavit on August 13 at 4.34pm. There’s nothing to stop me saying I now support someone else at 4.35pm. “The moment the SD is affirmed, it is about the past and not about the future. It would be different if the SD affirms that he has affirmed that he will vote for person X and has promised to person X that he will continue to vote for him until the deponent dies. “The same would go for the letters of support. Those are even more worthless because they are not affirmed and have no legal value as a document,” he said. However, these weaknesses do not mean that SDs or letters of support are not useful, according to constitutional lawyer Datuk Malik Imtiaz Sarwar. “Letters of support and SDs become essential when a time sensitive issue comes about, and at those points may be advantageous,” he said. When asked on what had set the precedent for lawmakers to declare or withdraw their support for a leader outside of the legislative houses, Malik pointed towards three cases. These were Stephen Kalong Ningkan , Datuk Amir Kahar Tun Mustapha v Tun Mohamed Said Keruak , and most recently the case revolving around what has come to be known as the 2009 Perak constitutional crisis — Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin v Zambry Abdul Kadir . In February 2009, the Sultan of Perak had sacked the then mentri besar — Nizar — after coming to the conclusion that the latter had lost majority support following interviews with all 59 assemblymen and receiving letters and statutory declarations of who they support. The High Court had initially ruled that Nizar could only be removed by a motion of no confidence on the floor of the state assembly and he was reinstated as Mentri Besar. However, this was overturned as a five-member Federal Court bench in 2010 ruled that the sultan was right to sack Nizar and appoint Zambry as the new Mentri Besar. To change such a precedent, a similar case would need to be taken up to the Federal Court, which would then need to overturn the previous decision.
Malaysia Latest News, Malaysia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Opec sticks to oil demand view despite virus, sees more US shale coming | Malay MailLONDON, Aug 12 — Opec on Thursday stuck to its prediction of a strong recovery in world oil demand in 2021 and further growth next year, despite concerns about the spread of the Delta coronavirus variant that has weighed on prices. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries in a...
Read more »
CIMB supports over 250,000 individuals, SMEs under payment assistance programme | Malay MailKUALA LUMPUR, Aug 12 — CIMB Bank Bhd and CIMB Islamic Bank Bhd has supported over 250,000 individual and small and medium enterprise (SME) customers to-date under the CIMB Payment Assistance Programme since its launch on July 7, 2021. In a statement today, the group said, under the...
Read more »
Japan PM Suga's support ratings stagnate at 29pc, despite Tokyo Olympics | Malay MailTOKYO, Aug 13 ― Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga's support ratings hit 29.0 per cent in August, down 0.3 point from the previous month, a poll by Jiji news agency showed today, a sign the Tokyo Olympic Games failed to give a boost to the premier's popularity. Of total respondents, 55.2 per...
Read more »
Apple's child protection features spark concern within its own ranks, say sources | Malay MailSAN FRANCISCO, Aug 13 ― A backlash over Apple's move to scan US customer phones and computers for child sex abuse images has grown to include employees speaking out internally, a notable turn in a company famed for its secretive culture, as well as provoking intensified protests from leading...
Read more »
Afghanistan spiralling into failed state where al-Qaeda will thrive, UK says | Malay MailLONDON, Aug 13 ― Afghanistan is spiralling into a failed state and a civil war in which militant groups such as al-Qaeda will thrive and likely pose a threat again to the West, Britain's defence minister said today. After a 20-year war in Afghanistan, the United States has withdrawn most of its...
Read more »
Global stocks march on; Treasury yields, dollar hit by weak consumer confidence | Malay MailNEW YORK, Aug 14 — Global stock markets hit new record highs yesterday, boosted by forecast-beating corporate earnings, but the dollar and Treasury yields fell after data showed US consumer confidence plummeted in early August. The University of Michigan’s survey showed consumer confidence...
Read more »